Indian Higher Education: Causes of Deterioration in Quality and Measures of Improvement

 

Mahesh Pandey, Sachin Singh, Govind Singh

Research Scholar, Dept of Economics, University of Allahabad, India.

*Corresponding Author E-mail: maheshpandey344@gmail.com, sachin.singh0092@gmail.com govindthakursingh11@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

Indian higher education system is the third largest higher education system in the world. The failure and success of any nations depends on their human resource. The improvement of human resource is the responsibility of higher education system of any country. In this paper we have discuss on causes of deterioration in quality and measures of improvement in Indian education system. In this paper we have limited ourselves to mainly qualitative lag. Because today we are facing serious quality crisis in our education system.

 

KEYWORDS: Education, Quality, Human resource, WIPO, Universities, Demographic dividend.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

Indian higher education system is the third largest higher education system in the world after China and USA. Having the largest demographic dividend in the world, it is our responsibility to develop a vibrant system of education to transform them into human capital and pave the way of New India.

 

India has a great tradition of nurturing knowledge since ancient times, world's first university was in Nalanda (Bihar), which was known globally for advancement in almost all streams of knowledge like Mathematics, Political Science, Astronomy, Ethics, Science, and Medicine as well. But modern education system of India which is product of colonial rule, has not been adequate according to Indian needs which is yielding only limited development of innovative ideas and scientific temper as very foundation of this education system is established to provide clerks not scientists. 

 

Unlike USA, India Education system has pyramidal structure, pre-primary education level placed at bottom, in upward direction from pre-primary to primary, primary to secondary level and secondary level to higher education. Thus, higher education is on the top of pyramid of educational structure of India which can further classified into UG, PG and MPhil/PhD levels. In India almost 94 percent students enroll themselves in 369 state universities, and only 6 percent get to join 150 centrally funded institutions, on the other hand we only have 25.8 percent gross enrollment ratio in higher education.

 

Indian Education system is less dynamic and not able adopt the change in worlds’ dimensions, which results a lag between Indian Education Institutions and worlds’ best Institutions.  This lag can be classified into quantity and quality lags. In this paper we have limited ourselves to mainly qualitative lag. Today, we are facing serious quality crisis in our education system as in QS world universities ranking 2020 only 23 Indian institutes got place in top 1000 worlds’ best institutions.

 

QS World University Ranking 2021:Global Top 20

2021

2020

Institutions

Country

1

1

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

USA

2

2

Stanford University

USA

3

3

Harvard University

USA

4

4

California Institute of Technology

USA

5

5

University of Oxford

UK

6

6

ETH Zurich

Switzerland

7

7

University of Cambridge

UK

8

9

Imperial college London

UK

9

10

University of Chicago

USA

10

8

University college London

UK

11

   11=

National University of Singapore

Singapore

12

13

Princeton University

USA

13

   11=

Nanyang Technological University(NTU)

Singapore

14

18

Ecole Polytechnic Federale de Lausanne (EPFL)

Switzerland

15

16

Tsinghua University

China

16

15

University of Pennsylvania

USA

17

17

Yale University

USA

18

14

Comell University

USA

19

   18=

Columbia University

USA

20

20

University of Edinburgh

UK

Source: QS World University rankings

 

Indian Major Institutes in QS world rankings, 2020

Institutions

2018

2019

2020

IIT Bombay

179

162

152

IIT Delhi

172

172

182

IISc Bangalore

190

170

184

IIT madras

264

264

271

IIT Kharagpur

308

295

281

IIT kanpur

293

283

291

IIT Roorkie

431-440

381

383

University of Delhi

481-490

487

474

IIT Guwahati

501-550

472

491

Op Jindal Global University

0

0

751-800

Source: QS World University rankings

 

India’s Top 20 Asia Rank

2020

2019

Institution / University

34

33

IIT Bombay

43

40

Iit Delhi

50

48

IIT Madras

51

50

IISc Bengaluru

56

53

IIT Kharagpur

65

61

IIT Kanpur

67

62

University of Delhi

90

86

IITRoorkie

112

107

IIT Guwahati

114

106

University of Hyderabad

136

137

Jadavpur University

139

134

University of Culcutta

152

167

Institute of Chemical Technology, Mumbai

169

169

Anna University

175

180

Birla Institute of Technology and Science

177

156

Banaras Hindu University

177

187

University of Mumbai

188

241

IIT Indore

191

237

Savitribai Phule University,Pune

192

177

Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi

Source: QS World University rankings

 

Till now, Indians have got only Nine Nobel prize out of 597 Noble prizes distributed across the world.

 

Nobel Prize Winners From India

(Includes people of Indian origin)

Year

Name

Area

1913

Rabindra Nath Tagore

Literature

1930

C V Raman

Physics

1968

Har Gobind Khorana

Medicine

1979

Mother Teresa

Peace

1983

S. Chandrashekhar

Physics

1998

Amartya Sen

Economics

2009

V Ramakrishnan

Chemistry

2014

Kailash Satyarthi

Peace

2019

Abhijit banerjee

Economics

Source: thebetterindia.com

 

and if we talk about patents granted by WIPO (World Intellectual Property Organization), only12,387 patents granted to India, whereas China was granted with 4,20,144 patents and USA 3,18,829 patents in 2017.

 

Causes of deterioration in quality:

There are many issues which can classified into three structural problems; financial, administrative and regulatory problems.

Structural problems-

 

Unlike Europe and USA, Indian Higher Education system is very rigid and static in nature. We don’t update our old syllabus according to global changes and market needs. We don’t have any permanent body for syllabus upgradation.

 

Less flexibility found in course selection and time for its completion. In India most of the Bachelor courses have fixed syllabus and are lacking in interdisciplinary approach, like engineering and medical students hardly get chance to study in humanities and other important courses required for all round development of becoming a responsible and better citizen.

 

Unlike USA, India has fixed graduation period, for example for Bachelor of Arts 3 years is fixed, which results limited development of student persona as compared to western countries where 4+ year college system is followed.

 

While world best Universities such as Stanford and Harvard give more than 70 percent of its coursework syllabus as practical work, Indian Education Institutions still follow theoretical orientation rather than experimental approach.

 

There is very weak correlation between industry demands and educational institutions’ supply in India.

 

Indian Universities except few have very less exposure to International collaborations in terms of seminar, symposium, conferences and student exchange programs. Even, within India we don’t have unique national level platform for knowledge sharing among Universities and between research institutions and universities.

 

We don’t have unique academic calendar for universities and set global standard of teachings. We follow sub- standard pedagogy, where old inferior practices in research are followed which again lack required infrastructure, which is resulting brain drain, in which talented students go to abroad for better options.

 

Financial Issues:

1.     As percentage of its GDP India is only spending 3 percent on education sector and merely 0.7 percent is given to research and development in 2018-19, which is far less than China and USA.

2.     Inequality in allocation; centrally funded institutions get more finances than state funded institutions.

3.     Mostly Indian institutions don’t have its own source of finance, wholly depended upon Governments’ mercy.

 

Regulatory issues

1.     Education is subject of concurrent list in the Indian constitution, where both Centre and states can make policies on it, this dual system generates infirmities in syllabus, curriculum and academic calendar, which further creates differences in qualities of education.

2.     We have old system of education which is 10+2+3. (Kothari Commission)

3.     UGC and AICTE are nurtured as controller rather than facilitators.

4.     There are complexities in regulation as there are different types of universities having different degree of freedom such as deemed University and research University.

 

Apart from above there is problem of accessibility and affordability of education for deprived section and problem of gender inequality in accessibility.

 

Required measures:

1.     India needs to spend more on education sector as per its GDP expenditure at least 6 percent, developed better infrastructure as per Global standards.

2.     Government of India should establish Higher Education commission to monitor, supervise and regulate the whole higher education system.

3.     India need to develop an integrated education system from preprimary to higher education.

4.     Government of India should start Indian Education Services to serve in the best institute across the country

5.     Indian university should have autonomy in term of finance, administration and academic curriculum.

6.     There should be an all India Research Institute to develop best practices in research, and generate creative ideas.

 

India should replace the old colonial Education system by an indigenously developed, value based education system as per global standards and India’s need.

 

HRD ministry through National Institute Ranking Framework should not only rank the institute but also provide the corrective measures.

Apart from above measures, there are some other measures suggested in Kasturirangan Report-

 

1-There should be National Higher Educational Regulating Authority for better regulation in HES.

2-Separate the NAAC from UGC to provide better accreditation

3-HES should be categorized in three levels; research institutes, Universities focused only on teaching and colleges focusing only on under graduation.

 

On the basis of above analysis an SWOT analysis of Indian higher education can be done-

 

Strength, it has potential to compete at global level like IITs and IIMs are globally known.,

Weakness, lacking in finance, infrastructure and better regulations.,

Opportunity, largest demographic dividend in the world.,

 

Threats, if demographic dividend could not be converted into human capital, it would merely become demographic burden.

 

Following goal-4 of SDGs (Education for all- ensure equitable, inclusive and quality education with the promotion of lifelong learning opportunities for all by 2030 government of India has taken many major steps like NIRF for ranking, Institutes of Eminence for greater autonomy and better finance, NEET and NTA for transparency in admission. Government of India has also launched a platform named DIKSHA for teacher training. As a result of these measures, few improvements can be noticed such as number of patents in R&D is increased substantially in 2018, enrollment in PhD has also increased in STEM. But still we are lagged behind as compared to other developing countries and there is large scope of improvement and many other steps needs to be taken to improve the quality of education and to achieve the target of new education policy of increasing the GER by 50% till 2035.

 

REFERENCES:

1.      Mishra, S. (2006), "Quality Assurance in higher education: An introduction", National Assessment and Accreditation council, Bangalore: Commonwealth of Learning (COL) Van Conver, Canada, 17

2.      Higher education in India: Twelfth five year plan (2012-17) and beyond FICCI Higher Education Summit 2012.

3.      New Week, Special Report: the Education Race, August 18-25-2011.

4.      60th annual report. University Grants Commission, 2013-14 (pp-50-78)

5.      PWC report on "Indian-Higher Education System: Opportunities for Private Participation, 2012.

6.      Sanat Kaul, " Higher Education in India: Seizing the Opportunity", working paper no. 179, 2006.

7.      British Council, Understanding India: the future of higher education and Opportunities for International Cooperation 2014.

8.      Yojana 2016: Transforming India School Education: Policy Concerns and Priorities.

 

Websites:

·       en.w.wikipedia.org

·       Business-standard.com

·       Vajiram ias.com

·       the betterindia.com

·       economictimes.com

·       www.wipo.int

·       www.topuniversities.com

 

 

 

Received on 23.03.2022         Modified on 12.04.2022

Accepted on 24.04.2022      ©AandV Publications All right reserved

Res.  J. Humanities and Social Sciences. 2022;13(2):113-116.

DOI: 10.52711/2321-5828.2022.00019